Re: AW: The Bach Choral Dilemma (Luis Felipe de Oliveira )

Subject: Re: AW: The Bach Choral Dilemma
From:    Luis Felipe de Oliveira  <luisfol(at)BOL.COM.BR>
Date:    Sat, 1 Feb 2003 21:38:59 -0300

Mr. wolf said: > The role of sheet music has traditionally been that of conveying > authoritative performance instructors to contemporary performers. Unfortunaly, I disagree. We have lots of examples of comtemporary music with not so authoritative performance instructions. Al least not concerned with traditional music notition. Like the pretty important compositional and aesthetic explorations of Cage in, for example, Variations. Or in The kind of Denmark of Morton Feldman, for percution. In such a work the notation don't instruct even the instruments or the rithmic patterns involved, given a wonderful liberty to a creative participation of a permformer. > Baroque > notation may appear almost empty of instructions to performers specializing > in late romantic repertoire, while Jazz notation seems equally empty to > classical musicians who are not familiar with the notational conventions > associated with the style. A documentary or conservation function of music > notation is a relatively recent notion, associated with both the rise of > historical musicology, with modern intellectual property law, and with a > contemporary musical repertoire not based upon a stable set of performing > conventions. I also agree with you about the recent interest of notation for the musicologists. But seems to me that the empty notation of barroque music is owed by the fact that composers did not have to write everything as precisely as we would like, because the musicians in that period knowed how to play, how to make the ornamentation and so on. They was imbeded in that music style. As the jazz musicians nowadays know how to play in really jazz vibes with just melody and chords in music sheets. Regards Luis Felipe Oliveira -- Post-graduation student in Cognitive Science and Philosophy of Mind at São Paulo State University; Graduated in Composition at São Paulo State University. Marília - SP - Brazil •

This message came from the mail archive
maintained by:
DAn Ellis <>
Electrical Engineering Dept., Columbia University